Café Discovery: The Unfather

( – promoted by undercovercalico)

Every year is the same.  Father’s Day shows up, an uninvited guest which has already used up the first three days of its visit (as per the old saying) and is beginning to resemble the dead fish way too much.

father

O.E. fæder, from P.Gmc. *fader (cf. O.N. faðir, Ger. vater), from PIE *p@ter (cf. Sanskit pitar−, Gk. pater, L. pater, O.Pers. pita, O.Ir. athir “father”), presumably from baby-speak sound like pa. The classic example of Grimm’s Law, where PIE “p−” becomes Gmc. “f−.”  Spelling with −th− (16c.) reflects widespread phonetic shift in M.E. that turned −der to −ther in many words; spelling caught up to pronunciation in 1500s (cf. burden, murder).  Fatherland (1623) is a loan-translation of Ger. Vaterland, itself a loan-translation of L. patria (terra), lit. “father’s land.”  Father’s Day dates back to 1910 in Spokane, Wash., but was not widespread until 1943, in imitation of Mother’s Day.

Online Etymology Dictionary

I mostly want to go hide somewhere, so I’ll mostly be watching men play golf.  Go figure.  It’s most assuredly not a good way to avoid Father’s Day.

Last year I wrote the following, which flashes back to an even earlier post in another SpaceTime.  It made the Rec List at the Orange.  Think of it as a way for me not to have to write something new.

The Unfather

Once upon a time in the City by the Bay, up where the longhairs roamed, a guy (from all outward appearances) was once again rejected from a place of belonging and tried to end it all…again.  Fortunately for our story, he was too stoned to figure out that if he needed something sharp to slit his wrists, all he needed to do was break a window.  If 20/20 hindsight had any power, he’d have been dead long ago.  But he’s not…

What does one do when one is so excruciatingly depressed about not finding a way to fit in even with goddamned hippie freaks?  Our protagonist ended up at the I/Thou Coffee Shop, next door to the Straight Theater, playing chess.  And winning.  One could keep playing if one kept winning, even if one didn’t have enough wherewithal to purchase anything.  During the course of the the run, a young woman sat down to watch.  She asked if he were a virgin.  He lied and said, “No.”  She offered our hero a place to sleep.  She took his viginity.

On such events are history hung.  There would be no story if he had told the truth.

Mucho drugs later and events involving stealing cigarettes for a living (not me, her), we ended up in Joplin, MO, in her parents’ house with her pregnant.  And me trapped by the ethos of my past.  I had a responsibility.



So here I was trying to be a father when I was still really hazy about why I had to be a man, looking at at least eighteen years.  Of course, I had some role models to try to emulate.  They would be my own alcoholic racist of an old man who never once said he was proud of me or his father, who called his wife Woman (It wasn’t until after I transitioned and returned to Oregon for a visit that I learned that my grandmother’s original name).  Or television characters from Father Knows Best, Donna Reed and Ozzie and Harriet.  I guess I tried to navigate everything as best I could.  I did the full 18 and a few more out of fear and ignorance about what to do next.

And I raised a damn fine child.  Here’s something I wrote about her back in 1996, on the OWLS email list for lesbians over 40 (I’m one of the founding members).

My daughter is a lesbian, something I think I had an inkling of when she was in about 4th grade.  I’ve been positive about it since junior high, at least.  I tried to be there for her if she ever wanted to talk but knowing that it was something only she could decide whether or not to tell me.  Actually, Jen never did tell me.  She told her mother and I got it from her.  Maybe Jen knew that I already knew.

High school was hard for her.  She had a lesbian friend in junior high whose mother was also lesbian and used to hang around over there a lot.  But then we moved to Arkansas and it became a lot harder for her.  She made some friends in drama class (that the teacher is a lesbian is a poorly kept secret) but she seemed to have trouble fitting in with the people here.

She eventually went to Lincoln to visit some friends who went from UCA to University of Nebraska for grad school.  While there, she met Julie, her partner, and they have now been together over seven years.  Last year they bought a house.  It was Julie who got me on the net at subscribed to the Sappho list.  She works as a bookbinder at the UNL library.

I can’t tell you how pleased I have been that Jen has found someone she loves and somewhere she fits.  She has friends there…she’s known as an excellent dungeon mistress amongst her friends (get your minds out of the gutter 🙂  I’m talking Dungeon’s and Dragons…hehe).  At the Brandon Teena Vigil, I met one of her friends, a professor at UNL, who told me that Jen has been a very vocal supporter of transsexual people in the community in Lincoln.  I can’t tell you how proud this made me feel.  And Julie is doing grad work in Women’s Studies looking at the transgenderism of Willa Cather and its influence on her writing (Willa Cather attended UNL dressed as a male, calling herself William Cather).

I’ve visited them several times now and I think Jen is really happy with her life.  As my .sig file says, that’s really all that is important.  It’s certainly what is most important to me.

We decided long ago that “father” probably wasn’t the appropriate term for my relationship with Jen.  I am her parent.

Jen will be 39 this August.  She and Julie now live in Santa Cruz, where Julie works and studies at UC-Santa Cruz and Jen works at a Kinko’s.  We get together whenever I am in the Bay Area.  I’m Julie’s parent-out-law.

But there isn’t any Parent-out-law Day and I have to suffer through this one, during which it will be displayed 6 to 10 times every hour, exactly how I should have been a father to my child, when all I really wanted was to be her mother.

48 comments

Skip to comment form

    • Robyn on June 15, 2008 at 20:05
      Author

  1. thing is that you love one another.

    My father was a manic depressive alcoholic who desperately wanted to be a good parent and frankly wasn’t for a long time. Even once we re-connected he did some annoying things like bringing whatever girlfriend he was dating along on father/daughter time when I was a teenager.

    At some point when I was in my early or mid-twenties we had a little honesty session that hurt him very much. He heard some things he did not want to hear. Now I see him as a flawed but decent man. I was hardly the perfect child.

    • Alma on June 15, 2008 at 20:26

    really, really beautiful.  🙂

    You did a damn fine job of raising your daughter from what I know about her.

    I got a big laugh out of this:

    she’s known as an excellent dungeon mistress amongst her friends (get your minds out of the gutter 🙂  

    cause my son is too, well master, and not mistress.

    At the end of your piece you mentioned something that I was just talking about with an online friend yesterday.

    when all I really wanted was to be her mother

    This friends niece has just come out as being a lesbian, and has a partner.  And while her parents aren’t being as supportive as one might hope, my friend and her mother both are.  The girls grandmother told the girls father that God doesn’t make mistakes and love is beautiful.  But I digress.  My friend figured out years ago that her niece is a lesbian, and is so happy she finally came out.  That lead to me talking about one of my favorite cousins.  That the family always knew he was “gay” because even as a tyke, when playing house he wanted to be Mommy.  Unfortunatly he didn’t get the support from his immediate family, and we’ve lost touch.  As the years have gone by, I’ve figured that he is probably really a straight transgendered female.  I’ve always wished there was a way to let him know that his family in MI would welcome him, or her, if that be the case.

  2. that hold out an ideal so often not realized are hard on many of us.

    My biological father is totally incapable of being anything other than an acquaintance in my life. So I don’t celebrate anything today except people like you and others who have meant so much to your children.  

    • RiaD on June 15, 2008 at 21:42

    excruciatingly lovely….

    a question?

    do you celebrate mothers day? (i mean as the mom)

    just wondering

  3. as you become.

    happy parent’s day.

  4. for some bizarre reason it cheered me up. What a surreal society where our lives are reduced to story book, made up, definitions of our various roles and transitions. I hate mothers day as all it does is make me feel uh oh… I sucked. Actually my kids now that they are parents seem to realize  that being a parent does not mean you stop being you, they seem to be to busy dealing with their own various identities, all in one life.

    I find the applying norms to your life, in a society which  calls any deviation from those dysfunctional, just makes you really dysfunctional. As my granddaughter says were all only human, we should rejoice at our difference not try to be what a greeting card or the TV tells us is a ‘good parent’. Your children are lucky to have a parent with the courage to take a journey outside the bounds of artificially imposed norms, one who knows that happiness, is being yourself, not trapped in definitionsfrom  Hallmark marketing slogans. Sounds like your daughter received what many don’t a way to be herself, and love herself.

    • Metta on June 16, 2008 at 20:04

    even though I’m abnormally normal. I don’t really like the regular holidays at all.  The solstices are may favorites.  I hate the questions at work or the grocery store “what are you doing for Valentines, Mother’s Day, fathers’s day?”, pick a day.  Is it any of their business or do they just want to validate their own plans or purchases?  It’s a bit too “George Bush says go shopping” for me.

    Although, one can guess how I’d feel if there was no official day to honor mothers yet one for fathers.  I think that would seem mightily unfair. On a heart level, I empathize with you.

    In my mind I don’t care if things get broken down and then something real and authentic emerges; Like Parent Day or Parent-out-Law day. From the point of veiw of this discussion, to define what the Christian right is afraid of it’s the breakdown of traditions that have Christian origins.  They mold and hold the family together through out the year blending faith and commercialism.  It’s as if the utter collapse of society will follow if we don’t follow the prescribed holiday schedule!

    Happily my family is pretty relaxed about the whole schmear of holidays, from birthdays to Christmas.  I’m pro-vacation though!!!

Comments have been disabled.