Don’t Give To The Red Cross

If you want to donate to the tornado survivors in Tennessee, Kentucky, Mississippi, Alabama and Arkansas, a better bet would be to make your donation to any charity other than the Red Cross. Other info can be found in this diary.

Because the Red Cross is actually an organization which, per a commenter under the above-mentioned diary,

is thoroughly politicized, the Bush hacks who aren’t competent enough for government work are corralled there.

There are too many worthy charities to waste money on that quasi-governmental mess.

by lgcap


What has gotten me riled up about this topic was reading about the Red Cross in remarks under that tornado diary and remembering how, when I used to post under another blog, one of the commenters who’s a physician said that as a Red Cross volunteer he’d wanted to go into New Orleans after the flood and had been told at the time that he couldn’t–the city was too dangerous.

This didn’t make sense to me–I mean, aren’t places where disasters have happened usually dangerous in some way or another? But the Red Cross’ reasoning comes to light in this following remark, also under the above-linked diary:

I’m sorry, but Red Cross…

….as an organization permanently lost me for their support after their horrendous performance during Katrina in New Orleans and their “buy in” to the whole  racist theme that the city was too dangerous to enter and that rendering help would mean residents wouldn’t be evacuated….even as 10s of thousands were suffering and in need. There was no excuse for that….  That was really F’ckd up.

by LakeSuperior

And it’s not just anonymous Daily Kos bloggers who say something’s “F’ckd up” in the Red Cross–here’s more:

While many were outraged that the Red Cross failed to enter New Orleans, unsafe conditions and reports of shootings and lootings may have informed the decision. The Red Cross is not chartered to conduct search and rescue operations.

We “will not put [our] own workers in harm’s way,” Red Cross spokesperson Renita Hosler told RAW STORY.

Hosler explained that the Red Cross was “at the table” with “Emergency Management” numerous times while conditions deteriorated in New Orleans and that a decision was reached that if the group set up shop within the city, it might encourage others to come back, creating a secondary crisis.

Hosler confirmed that authorities turned down repeated offers by the Red Cross to enter New Orleans with supplies. New Orleans, she asserted, was considered too unsafe for the Red Cross to enter.

The article also says that the Red Cross,

although mandated by its Code of Conduct to remain independent of government, is officially part of the Bush Administration’s national security apparatus.

Hmmm. This means that the Red Cross, at the time New Orleans flooded had been, instead of the helpful, rescuing charity its proponents paint it as being, a partner in crime with a BushCo which had been imposing its Final Solution in Louisiana. This makes the Red Cross, like BushCo, is guilty of genocide–standing idly by as poor people in Louisiana drowned.

And it was also mentioned under the tornado diary how the Red Cross’ response to the wildfires in California had been good and that its being under new management could be the reason. Maybe so–but then, maybe that area of California doesn’t have a large concentration of poor people of color that BushCo wanted to ethnically cleanse.

Back to Louisiana–there should be some way bereaved families, knowing that the Red Cross’ inaction had contributed to the loss of their loved ones, could institute legal action against that organization–and I don’t mean by merely filing a lawsuit. That would be too kind. Instead, those responsible for the Red Cross’ decision not to go into New Orleans should be charged with murder.

Where’s Mark Geragos when you need him?


    • Tigana on February 8, 2008 at 02:58


    How you can help New Orleans

    Three ways you can help

    First: Inform yourself. The gap between how the mass media portrays New Orleans and what actually is happening there is huge. Take advantage of the info on

    Second: Come visit. For all its current challenges, New Orleans is still one of the most fascinating cities on earth. For food, for music, for history, for people, you won’t find better.

    Third: Contribute to the rebuilding with your time or money or both.

    The city’s needs are still acute and will be for years to come. New Orleans is worth the effort. In fact, it will probably pay you back more than you could ever give if you’re open to receive its unique gifts.

    If you are an Internet professional and might like to donate your expertise and services, please enter your info in the Internet Professionals for New Orleans (IPNO) Database.

    Helping organizations you can trust

    Common Ground – Solidarity Not Charity

    Food Not Bombs – They fed the city during its darkest hour

    Greater New Orleans Food Bank – Food is fundamental

    Levees.Org – New Orleans needs proper levees

Comments have been disabled.